# Generation 2/2 — judge panel

Judges: google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite, Qwen/Qwen3.5-27B


## lineage C — total 41.00
- **google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite** total 43.0 — Low motion score due to static repeating frames; excellent transformation progress to hawk.
  - {"silhouette_anatomy": 8.0, "geometry_material": 8.0, "lighting_composition": 7.0, "motion": 4.0, "morph_continuity": 7.0, "morph_pacing": 9.0}
- **Qwen/Qwen3.5-27B** total 39.0 — Transformation is complete but geometry is chaotic. The jump from human to this abstract bird form lacks believable continuity.
  - {"silhouette_anatomy": 6.0, "geometry_material": 7.0, "lighting_composition": 8.0, "motion": 5.0, "morph_continuity": 4.0, "morph_pacing": 9.0}

## lineage B — total 36.50
- **google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite** total 41.0 — Great morphological transition to hawk, but zero motion across the three current sequence frames.
  - {"silhouette_anatomy": 8.0, "geometry_material": 6.0, "lighting_composition": 7.0, "motion": 2.0, "morph_continuity": 9.0, "morph_pacing": 9.0}
- **Qwen/Qwen3.5-27B** total 32.0 — Static frames prevent motion scoring. Anatomy is a strange hybrid; transformation pace is complete.
  - {"silhouette_anatomy": 6.0, "geometry_material": 5.0, "lighting_composition": 4.0, "motion": 0.0, "morph_continuity": 7.0, "morph_pacing": 10.0}

## lineage A — total 0.00
- **google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite** total 0.0 — All generated frames are completely black, showing rendering failure.
  - {"silhouette_anatomy": 0.0, "geometry_material": 0.0, "lighting_composition": 0.0, "motion": 0.0, "morph_continuity": 0.0, "morph_pacing": 0.0}
- **Qwen/Qwen3.5-27B** total 0.0 — No frames to look at; all provided images are blank black screens.
  - {"silhouette_anatomy": 0.0, "geometry_material": 0.0, "lighting_composition": 0.0, "motion": 0.0, "morph_continuity": 0.0, "morph_pacing": 0.0}

**Winner:** C
**Eliminated:** A
**Bred:** C x B -> A